Auto Insurance Center logo
(844) 777-5466
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Insurance Offers in Your Area!
Get FREE Insurance Quotes:
  • Save up to $400 on average.
  • After getting instant quotes, there's no commitment to buy.
  • Spend 6 of the most useful minutes of your life with us.
  • Delivering car insurance coverage since 1997.
  • Your information is safe with us!

Best Cheap Auto Insurance in Pittsburgh 15236

You would be surprised how much insurance rates can vary zip code to zip code even if the zip codes are within the same metropolitan area. This can be for various reasons including higher or lower crime rates in a specific zip code area, accident statistics in that zip code, traffic density in different parts of the city, and even different weather conditions depending on what part of the metro area you are in. This can become even more interesting if you live on the border of a different zip code yet your are paying more for insurance than you would if you lived right across the street. While some people will use this to their advantage and give their insurance company a different address than their actual address to save some money it is not advisable as this may be seen as a form of fraud. 

To find out what your auto insurance rates will be for you zip code either fill out the quick quote form above or call one or more of the local agents below. It is best to call more than one to get them to compete for your business so that you can get the cheapest rates possible. Many people would rather avoid this effort because its more work but its one of the best ways to get cheap auto insurance quotes.

  • Company
  • Description
  • Address
  • Contact
  • Switched form Allstate on my auto and home. Saved over 700 dollars on my auto and 52 on the home..

  • I recently had my first auto insurance claim and the McElhinny Insurance handled everything wonderfully. They answered all my questions and took the time to ease my mind. Thank You to the staff there, you have earned a customer for life.

  • Great Customer Service I have been with McElhinny Insurance for 13 years; the customer service is excellent and the staff is very accomodating. I would recommend them to anyone.

  • I've never met Tom Sterling as, from my experience, you rarely if ever meet the actual agent in a State Farm office. But, the office personnel are not very friendly. I have dealt with one person, Christine I believe, who was very helpful and nice. However, even if I call to talk to her and have to get transferred through someone else, my call is always handled as a nuisance. There is often hostility in the voices of the people who answer and I have been treated as an unnecessary interruption. I do not mean that I call to complain either. When I recently called to have the declaration page for my renter's insurance faxed to the rental office where I live, the tone and shortness I experienced from the person who answered the phone was astounding. When I asked if it could be faxed I was told (with annoyance) that it would be faxed but not the same day. Everyone gets busy. But if I pay my insurance and need proof of that insurance for my living arrangements, I feel like taking 2 minutes to fax something should not be treated as a burden. The previous office I was associated with was wonderful (Mary Cath Herforth in Monroeville). I never experienced anything like what I have experienced at this office. Shortly after transferring offices (because we moved out of the area of Mary Cath), we made an appointment to meet with someone. When we came in for the appointment, one person literally rolled their eyes and pointed to "upstairs" where we needed to go. We basically wondered around until we found the right office. Overall, I would not recommend this office due to the rude way with which customers are handled.