Auto Insurance Center logo
(844) 777-5466
Enter Your Zip Code to Get
Insurance Offers in Your Area!
Get FREE Insurance Quotes:
  • Save up to $400 on average.
  • After getting instant quotes, there's no commitment to buy.
  • Spend 6 of the most useful minutes of your life with us.
  • Delivering car insurance coverage since 1997.
  • Your information is safe with us!

Best Cheap Auto Insurance in Fort Myers 33912

You would be surprised how much insurance rates can vary zip code to zip code even if the zip codes are within the same metropolitan area. This can be for various reasons including higher or lower crime rates in a specific zip code area, accident statistics in that zip code, traffic density in different parts of the city, and even different weather conditions depending on what part of the metro area you are in. This can become even more interesting if you live on the border of a different zip code yet your are paying more for insurance than you would if you lived right across the street. While some people will use this to their advantage and give their insurance company a different address than their actual address to save some money it is not advisable as this may be seen as a form of fraud. 

To find out what your auto insurance rates will be for you zip code either fill out the quick quote form above or call one or more of the local agents below. It is best to call more than one to get them to compete for your business so that you can get the cheapest rates possible. Many people would rather avoid this effort because its more work but its one of the best ways to get cheap auto insurance quotes.

  • Company
  • Description
  • Address
  • Contact
  • I am rating the Cathy Sink Agency as a one because a zero rating was not possible. I have been a loyal Allstate customer for the last 24 years and never made a claim of any kind. I have insured both my autos and my home through them and everything went smoothly until I filed a claim. We were involved in an accident that was not our fault. The other driver freely admitted fault, the police report reflected it was not our fault and witnesses also stated the other driver was at fault. We immediately contacted our Allstate agent and things went downhill from there. Our agent gave us wrong and misleading information, in fact he lied outright to us. He claimed we would be reimbursed for any out of pocket expenses we had. He also told us the other insurance company had approved all reimbursements and would send us a check within the next seven business days. When the seven days came and went we contacted him and that’s when he really got rude and extremely unprofessional. He accused us of writing emails critical of Allstate and that was not helping our claim. Then we started getting emails from Cathy Sink herself. She apparently got our agent’s side of the story and told us we would never see any further reimbursement. Not once did we get a phone call from either the agent or Cathy Sink to ask for our side of the story. I can only imagine what would have happened if the accident were our fault. It comes down to a lack of trust and confidence in Allstate, especially the Cathy Sink Agency, and an extreme lack of customer service.